Here's
how you can tell when a Disney theme park ride is really
successful: It outlives its source material in the public's esteem.
This can only occur under specific circumstances. Firstly, the source
material has to become obscure despite a) having been well-regarded
enough at one point to be adapted into a ride and b) having the ride
around to reinforce it for millions of vacationers each year.
Secondly, the ride has to be good enough to draw queues despite
losing the power of brand name recognition.
As you can imagine, it doesn't happen very often. You can probably
count the genuine instances on one hand. Splash Mountain is the big
one, due to being a unique thrill ride based on a movie that is not
just obscure by mainstream standards but actually banned. But let's
not overlook Mr. Toad's Wild Ride, whose inspiring movie is hardly
any more known these days. I mean, when was the last time you
watched it?* As for how it survives despite its source material
falling off the radar, the ride concept—joyriding around various
parts of old-timey England in an old-timey horseless carriage—pretty
much speaks for itself.
But I think there's more to it than that. I have been known, in
passing, to use the word “transgressive” in regard to Mr. Toad's
Wild Ride, without going into any details. But how else to describe
it? I can't think of another Fantasyland-style dark ride that breaks
the mold the way this one does. The usual methodology for plotting
out one of these things is to take scenes from the movie and rebuild
them physically so guests can ride through. They
don't always get the perspective right, but as a rule, you can
hop on a dark ride and see events you remember from the movie.
Mr. Toad's Wild Ride...does not do that. It kind of does the
opposite, in fact. It focuses on events that drive the plot of the
movie** but actually occurred off-screen.*** The ride has been
around forever and we take it for granted, but it's pretty bizarre
when you think about it. We must consider that when Disneyland
opened, The Adventures of Ichabod and Mr. Toad was only six
years old, well remembered by the public. Did it seem at all weird to
1950s guests that the other Fantasyland dark rides were fairly
straightforward recreations and then this one
was...well...fanfiction?